|
7.
Chemical Economics and Issues involved in the Chemical Industry and the Life
Cycle of a Product
7.1 Introductory questions to be answard
What economic factors
are involved in the manufacture of a chemical compound?
Why are the costs to
make one chemical compound greater than for another?
What are the various cost
factors?
Are there environmental and pollution issues to deal with.?
What is a
batch process? What is a continuous process?
Where is it best to locate a
chemical works? Recycling - why recycle eg metals and plastics?
All of these aspects of the chemical manufacturing and mining
industries are discussed.
7. Chemical & Pharmaceutical
Industry Economics & Sustainability
7.2 An introduction to using the
Earth's Resources and Sustainable Development
The chemical industry uses the Earth’s
natural
resources to manufacture a huge range of useful products.
In order for
the chemical industry to operate sustainable, chemists look for ways to minimise the use of limited resources,
energy consumption, waste products and the environmental impact in the manufacture
of these products. In the chemical industry,
sustainable development is often referred to as 'green chemistry' with
respect to, and for, our current and future environment.
Chemists look for ways of disposing of products at the end
of their useful life in ways that ensure that materials and stored
energy are used efficiently.
The effects of pollution, disposal of waste
products and changing land all have a significant effect on the
environment. Environmental chemists research how human activity has
affected the Earth’s natural cycles, and how damaging effects can be
minimised.
For centuries human societies use the
Earth’s resources to provide warmth, shelter, food and transport, but
the pressure has increased on using natural resources, as ever supplemented by agriculture
to provide food, timber,
clothing, fuels from oil and metals from mineral ores.
Most materials from the Earth, oceans and
atmosphere are finite resources (limited, may run out in the
future e.g. oil), but are being continually processed to provide energy and materials.
Chemistry
plays an important role in improving agricultural and industrial
processes to provide new products and in sustainable development.
Sustainable development must meet the needs of
current generations without compromising the ability of future
generations to meet their own needs.
Many natural products are being supplemented or replaced by
agricultural and synthetic products, preferably from renewable resources (naturally renewed, shouldn't run out e.g.
timber) rather than the increasingly depleted finite
resources.
We have to balance the social and
economic benefits of finite resources (e.g. jobs in the local economy) with
the environment impact of using these resources (e.g. air/water pollution,
mining and waste created).
In the manufacture of
products, the chemical industry is always looking at alternative
more sustainable manufacturing
processes with increased efficiency, reducing use of fossil fuel
based energy, sources of raw materials with less impact on the environment,
better catalysts. Recycling can also play its part.
Catalysts enable lower temperature reaction
conditions and faster rates of production - reducing energy needs and
even catalysts can be recycled and can you recycle unused reactants,
reducing the quantity of fresh raw materials needed.
Can any use for found for waste products? How are
they best treated and disposed of if of no use? Recycled?
Can by-products (other substances formed alongside
the main desired product) be sold on for some other chemical
manufacturing process?
For more on recycling
see
Economic & environmental Issues and
recycling of various materials
For more on selected examples chemical processing see
Contact Process, the importance of sulfuric acid
Ammonia
synthesis/uses/fertilisers
Oil Products
See also section 8.
Products of the
Chemical and Pharmaceutical Industries their Impact on Us
and section 9.
The Principles &
Practice of Chemical
Production - Synthesising Molecules
both related to this page, and
examples of how we use materials
Survey of properties related to uses of a wide variety of materials -
metals, polymers, composites, ceramics
7.3 Three important
'definitions' for section 7. in more detail
(i) Natural resources
We obtain natural resources from the
atmosphere, earth and sea form without any initial human input.
e.g. nitrogen from air to make ammonia, mineral
ores for metals, oil for organic molecules including fuels.
Some natural products are being replaced with
synthetic products -
see materials
page for examples.
The
development of fertilisers has enhanced agricultural product ion of
food - an example of enhancing the production of a natural product
to increase crop yields.
You should be
aware of the 'pros and cons' of extracting useful materials from the
environment e.g. useful metals and fuels and countless other
products we use, but sometimes at great harm to the natural world
and global warming is ever present.
(ii) Finite resources
A finite resource is a non-renewable
material/energy resource that cannot renew itself at a sufficient rate
for sustainable economic extraction in meaningful human time-frames
e.g.
organically-derived fossil fuels like oil which take millions of years
to form from plant and animal remains, mineral ores which cannot be
replaced including uranium ores (and derived plutonium) for nuclear
fuels. Unfortunately most materials we used
are based on finite non-renewable raw material sources e.g. our use of
metals and plastics.
Finite resources
usually require several man-made processes to convert them into
useful products e.g.
fuels from the fractional
distillation of oil, the
extraction of metals from the
reduction of ores,
(iii) Renewable resources
A renewable resource is a natural material/energy
source of economic value that can be replaced or replenished in a
sustainable way.
e.g a renewable resource can be
replaced in the same
or less amount of time as it takes to utilise reduce the supply e.g.
plant material like trees-timber and agricultural food crops, wind power, hydroelectric power,
fresh water.
See
index of links to the extraction and uses of the Earth's resources
7.4 What
do we mean by sustainability?
The idea of sustainability is to
allow for the current needs of society without damaging the environment
for future generations.
Chemistry can play a big part in
developing a more sustainable chemical industry e.g. (i) developing
catalysts to make processes more efficient, like requiring less energy
or producing less waste and (ii) using new chemical methods to extract
valuable materials from previously discarded waste.
Copper is a good example of (ii)
using
bioleaching and phytomining.
Sustainable development should focus
on renewable resources, not the unsustainable finite resources.
The production of many useful
products requires large inputs of energy, much of it still obtained from
finite resources like oil and coal.
Large amounts of waste are also
produced, which have to dealt with in some way.
The more you can recycle a material,
the less energy is used and less overall waste produced AND the longer
the finite resource will last.
For detailed examples on
sustainability and recycling of metals see
Extraction and Purification of Copper, phytomining & bioleaching
Economic & environmental Issues and recycling
Recycling plastics
7.5 Some
basic economics of the chemical and pharmaceutical industry
-
Why aren't processes 100% efficient?
Typical reasons are:
- Loss in filtration of a solid
product, i.e. some may get through as very fine particles or more
likely dissolved in the liquid residue.
- Loss in evaporation if the
product is a volatile liquid.
- Loss in transferring liquids,
i.e. traces left on the sides of containers.
- The reaction may be an
equilibrium, so its impossible to get 100% yield anyway and this
means that the yield of an equilibrium reaction depends on
the conditions used.
- See also calculations sections
14.1
% purity of a product 14.2a
% reaction yield 14.2b
atom economy
- -
-
The
costs of making new substances
depends on many factors and these days the idea of 'sustainable
development' is really important and increasingly so!
- Factors such as atom economy
and % yield have already been discussed above.
- Price and quantity of energy
used (e.g. gas,
electricity etc.).
- Manufacturing processes should be
designed to work on the minimum possible energy, it reduces
costs and ultimately the impact of the manufacturing process on
the environment e.g. less energy used, less carbon dioxide
produced from burning fossil fuels, less pollution, better for
the environment.
- The unit cost of
energy, the less energy you need, the cheaper the process.
- Electrical energy is very expensive.
- Endothermic reactions may
need a high temperature, the higher the process temperature, the
more energy is needed.
- Sometimes exothermic reactions
produce energy that can be 'captured' by heat exchangers and put
to good use e.g. pre-heating reactants, making steam to drive an
electrical generator.
- -
-
Starting materials
(raw materials ==> chemical feedstock ==> reactants)
- Raw materials have
to be paid for before you have even made any product!
- Is the source of raw materials
sustainable?
- If the source of raw materials or
chemical feedstock is from a finite non-renewable resource e.g.
oil or mineral ores, then these resources become depleted, more
difficult to find or extract, since the best most convenient go
first, so ultimately their cost increases, so cost of product
increases.
- Non-renewable resources like
biomass from plants via photosynthesis, are a good example of a
renewable chemical feedstock source.
- Recycling
any unreacted chemicals (see
Haber Synthesis of Ammonia),
or
recycling plastics or metals from used products all help to keep
production costs down.
- Labour (wages).
All workers
should
be paid a reasonable wage! Some processes are labour intensive,
so wage bills rise. Many chemical processing plants are
automated which keeps the running costs down by lowering the
wage bill, though this does
increase the capital cost of setting up the chemical plant in
the first place because of the greater more advanced technology.
- Equipment (chemical plant e.g.
machines, reactors, heat transfer systems), building a large
chemical plant is a multi-million pound project, specialised
catalysts and high quality chemical engineering equipment don't
come cheaply!
- Speed of manufacture
(time
efficiency) - rates of
reaction factors are very important here.
- -
7.6 More on cost factors and batch processing versus
continuous processes
7.7 Factors to consider where to site a chemical works
TOP OF PAGE and
indexes
7.8 APPENDIX 1 LIFE CYCLE
ASSESSMENT OF A PRODUCT and an example analysed
A broader view of the
economics of manufacturing and using a product taking into account the
source of raw materials and disposal of the product after its useful
life

A
life cycle assessment
(LCA)
considers every stage of the 'life of a product' starting with
the raw material, making the product, using the product and finally
disposing of the product as usefully and as harmlessly as possible. The
idea is to look at the
total environmental impact of all stages, and all of
the 'aspects' have economic consequences for us all when introducing a
new product.
Life cycle assessment (LCA),
recycling and issues with assessing an LCA of a new product.
LCAs are carried out to assess the
environmental impact of products in each of four stages: (1) extracting and processing raw materials,
(2) manufacturing and packaging, (3) use and operation during its lifetime
and finally (4)disposal of the product at the end of its useful
life, including transport and distribution at each stage.
Energy, water,
resource consumption and production of some wastes can be fairly easily
quantified but allocating numerical values to pollutant effects is less
straightforward and requires value judgements.
Therefore an
LCA is not a purely
objective process. LCAs can be devised to evaluate a product but these
can be misused to reach pre-determined conclusions, eg
(i) in support of claims
for advertising purposes of vested interests of a company,
(ii) a personal
prejudiced opinion of someone carrying out the LCA assessment,
(iii) environmental impacts can
be selected, others may be ignored or perhaps not realised at the
time -the effect of CFCs on destroying the ozone layer is a good
example of unforeseen consequences!
Fortunately many products can be recycled e.g. shopping bags made from plastic, paper,
glass, metals etc.
You need to consider the advantages
of recycling metals, including economic implications and how recycling
can help preserve both the environment and the supply of valuable raw
materials. These are important aspects of a life time assessment for a
product that also involves consideration of the effect on the
environment of obtaining the raw materials, manufacturing the product,
using the product and disposing of the product when it is no longer
useful.
Choice
of material for the product - choosing, extracting and processing of raw materials
Air and water are raw
materials used in many processes, both are renewable resources.
Metals are obtained by mining
mineral ores and processing them to extract the metal, they are
non-renewable resources and use a lot of energy to obtain the pure
metal from mining and furnaces, which have waste and polluting consequences
- not good for the environment.
Many chemicals are
ultimately derived from the processing of crude oil and natural gas
in the petrochemical industry. These are non-renewable resources
(finite) and
we use them at quite a rate, hence they are very much a finite
resource and will not last forever. Both extracting the oil and gas
and refining it e.g. fractional distillation, further processing
like cracking, use lots of energy and so have pollution
side-effects.
Extracting resources can be
unsustainable due to high energy demands and waste materials made in
the process. Further energy demands are required to process the raw
material into a useful substance or chemical feedstock from which to
make other products. At the moment, much of this energy is derived
from finite sources.
If we can use less of a finite
resource, it will last longer and less impact on the environment.
Scientists and engineers are all working of lots of projects that
make our use of precious resources more sustainable.
Although a renewable
resource, biologist and biochemists are development crops that
give higher yields, preferably using the minimum of artificial
fertilisers. However, some developments, may involve genetic
engineering which is very controversial.
Chemists and chemical
engineers are constantly developing catalysts that enable
chemical reactions to be done using less energy and producing
less waste in many chemical process plants.
Manufacture
of the product and packaging it
Manufacturing any
chemical product inevitably uses energy as well as the raw materials
resources the chemical product is made from. Pollution arises from
burning fossil fuels e.g. acid rain from the oxides of sulfur and
nitrogen, other air pollutants like carbon monoxide, acidic gases, soot-carbon
particulates. There is also the added problem of the safe disposal
of waste products ..
.. some of which can
be recycled at the point of manufacture using the 'synthesis',
(especially for continuous production),
other 'waste' maybe
useful by-products which may be of value directly or converted to
another useful product, this reduces waste and helps the
economics of the overall production process
and some waste of no
value at all and sometimes at great cost, safely disposed of
without harm to the public or polluting the environment.
Use
of the product through its lifetime
Consequences
Will making and using
the product damage the environment?
Are ecosystems affected?
Are we
as humans affected by health issues by using the product?
How long will the product be used
for?
How long will the product last?
Does it have a long economic
and useful life without producing much waste, pollution or any other
negative environmental impact.
Using
non-electric cars causes pollution and global warming from burning fossil fuels like
those for petrol or diesel vehicles.
Over-use of fertilisers leaching out into rivers
and lakes causes eutrophication - deadly effects on aquatic
ecosystems.
Chemical pollutants can build up in food chains harming
top predators like birds of prey (historically the now banned DDT,
now PCB polymer plasticisers have entered the food chains).
We use
so many different chemicals that we don't always know whether they
are completely safe in some cases, not everything is as thoroughly
tested as much as they should, so there 'data gaps' in their
potential effects, particularly if they can accumulate in the
environment - pesticides and nano-materials is good cases.
Disposal
of product - safely? recycling?
Ideally as much as
possible of the product is recycled e.g. scrap metal, plastics,
paper, glass etc.
If nothing can be done
with the rest, the 'waste' goes to the ever increasing volume of
landfill sites which take up space and are polluting to the surrounding environment.
Landfill sites produce methane can be produced (a powerful greenhouse gas) and both land
and water may be polluted.
Large incineration plants can burn large
amounts of combustible waste, but this can still produce pollutants of
its own! Even collecting and transporting waste involves using
energy and associated pollution.
We are always looking for ways of reducing the use of resources
so the reduction in use, reuse and recycling
of materials by end users reduces the use of limited resources, energy
consumption, waste and environmental impacts i.e. sustainable development!
This
can be achieved to some extent by recycling and/or using renewable
resources, but this is not always practical or economic.
Metals, glass, building materials e.g.
bricks & stones,
clay ceramics and most plastics are produced from limited raw materials and much of
the energy used in the processes comes from limited resources e.g. oil.
Obtaining raw
materials from the Earth by quarrying and mining causes major environmental impacts.
Some products, like glass bottles, can be reused
in their original shape or they can be
crushed and melted to make different glass products. Other products cannot be
reused and so are recycled for a different use e.g. waste glass can be made into
glass fibres for insulation. This saves on energy and reduces
waste. Ideally you can separate the glass by colour and chemical
composition. One of the problems in recycling is too complex a
mixture to make it worthwhile to effect the separations.
Metals can be recycled by
melting and recasting or reforming into different products, though they must be
first collected from where they were used and separated from
other waste material.
The amount of
separation required for recycling depends on the material and the properties
required of the final product. For example, some scrap steel can be added to
iron from a blast furnace to reduce the amount of iron that needs to be
extracted from iron ore.
TOP OF PAGE and
indexes
7.9 Life Cycle Assessment for plastic and paper bags
The AQA GCSE chemistry course suggest students should
research and do a ....
|
Life Cycle Assessment stage |
Plastic carrier bag |
Paper bag |
|
1. Raw material resource |
finite crude oil |
renewable timber from
forests |
|
2. Manufacturing and packaging |
fractional distillation ==>
alkanes fraction ==> cracked ==> alkene ==> addition polymer (but
the other fractions have their uses, effectively little waste in the
process) |
plenty of energy used to pulp
timber, uses various chemicals in the process of making paper,
resulting in lots of waste that has to be dealt with |
|
3. Using the product in its
lifetime |
can be used a many times as
a domestic carrier bag, but only once as bin liner for kitchen or
garden waste. |
unless thicker paper, only used
once or a few times |
|
4. Disposal of product |
if collected appropriately it can
be recycled, but it is not usually biodegradable |
biodegradable, non-toxic and can
be recycled |
Which to use?
The plastic bag is quite cheap to produce in bulk and can be used many
times as a carrier bag, but it isn't biodegradable and its from a finite
non-renewable resource.
Biodegradable plastics are being developed, they are a bit more
costly, but we have deposited quite a few on our compost heap from the
kitchen bin!
The paper bag is recyclable/biodegradable and from a renewable source,
but uses harmful chemicals and more energy.
It would appear that although most plastic bags are not
biodegradable, they have a longer lifespan than paper bags, so may
overall be less harmful to the environment?
What you should grasp immediately is that in making an LCA assessment, it
doesn't necessarily mean that making a decision as to which bag to
manufacture and use is easy! Which would you choose and why on balance!
TOP OF PAGE and
indexes
What next?
Associated Pages
(Where next?)
ALL my GCSE
Level (~US grade 8-10) School Chemistry Notes
(students aged ~14-16)
Find your GCSE
science course for more help links to revision notes
ALL my Advanced Level pre-university
Chemistry Notes
(students aged ~17-18)
This is a BIG
website, you need to take time to explore it [SEARCH
BOX]
email doc
brown
Index of
selected pages describing industrial processes:
Limestone, lime
- uses, thermal decomposition of carbonates, hydroxides and nitrates
Enzymes and
Biotechnology
Contact Process, the importance of sulfuric acid
How can
metals be made more useful? (alloys of Al, Fe, steel etc.)
Instrumental Methods of Chemical Analysis
Chemical & Pharmaceutical Industry Economics & Sustainability
and Life Cycle Assessment
Products of the
Chemical & Pharmaceutical Industries & impact on us
The Principles & Practice of Chemical
Production - Synthesising Molecules
Ammonia
synthesis/uses/fertilisers
Oil Products
Extraction of Metals
Halogens
- sodium
chloride Electrolysis
Transition
Metals
Extra Electrochemistry
- electrolysis and cells
LINKS to Industrial Process
Pages involving electrolysis
12.
The electrolysis of molten aluminium oxide
- extraction of
aluminium from bauxite ore & anodising aluminium to
thicken and strengthen the protective oxide layer
13.
The extraction of sodium
from molten sodium chloride using the 'Down's Cell'
14.
The purification of
copper by electrolysis
15.
The purification of
zinc by electrolysis
16. Electroplating
coating
conducting surfaces with a metal layer
17.
Electrolysis of brine (NaCl(aq)) for the production of chlorine, hydrogen and sodium hydroxide
|
Based on the syllabus-specifications
for students taking the IGCSE/GCSE level chemistry examinations summary
revision notes and key points on economics of the chemical &
pharmaceutical industries for students taking the AQA
igcse/gcse chemistry notes on economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical
industries, Edexcel gcse
chemistry notes on economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical
industries, OCR 21st century GCSE
chemistry notes on economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical
industries, OCR gateway
GCSE chemistry notes on economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical
industries, WJEC gcse chemistry notes on economics of the chemical &
pharmaceutical industries, CCEA
gcse chemistry notes on economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical
industries for students taking CIE Cambridge igcse
chemistry, or any other GCSE or IGCSE level chemistry exams notes on
economics of the chemical & pharmaceutical industries, useful for US grade 9-10 chemistry courses,
Explaining the importance of life-cycle
assessment of a product
in GCSE level chemistry, What you need to know about life-cycle
assessment of a product for
GCSE level
chemistry,
Explaining the use of life-cycle assessment of a product knowledge in GCSE level chemistry, Examples of
life-cycle assessment of a product explained
when studying GCSE level chemistry, What is
the significance of life-cycle assessment of a product in GCSE level chemistry, describing and
explaining the theory of life-cycle assessment of a product when studying GCSE level chemistry, revision
notes for life-cycle assessment of a product in exams, online help for understanding
life-cycle assessment of a product, exam revision
notes for life-cycle assessment of a product, what do I need to learn about
life-cycle assessment of a product? revision summary for life-cycle assessment
of a product, learning notes for life-cycle assessment of a product, help to pass the
life-cycle assessment of a product
topic in an exam question, how to prepare for questions on life-cycle
assessment of a product in a GCSE
chemistry examination?
Website content © Dr
Phil Brown 2000+. All copyrights reserved on Doc Brown's Chemistry revision notes, images,
quizzes, worksheets etc. Copying of website material is NOT
permitted. Exam revision summaries & references to science course specifications
are unofficial.
What next?
Associated Pages
|
|